Greetings, reader!
I recently finished re-watching one of television’s finest sitcoms - Modern Family (2009-2020). I’ve always wanted to do a post where I rank the very best lines from an entire TV show, but the challenge has evaded me, because not even my memory is up for the task - unless I watch the show from beginning to end with this task in mind, pausing to make notes every time a line so good that it might make the cut comes up. So, that’s exactly what I did!
These are the very best lines of dialogue from the show’s eleven-season run, ranked based on a combination of the writing and the actor’s delivery in the situation. I only chose individual lines, although the surrounding context obviously affects my view of a line because dialogue doesn’t exist in a void. Before we get to the actual honorable mentions, I have to share two absolute diamonds that would’ve probably made the cut but had to be disqualified because the joke consists of multiple lines in a way that no one line could represent the whole thing.
First of all, we have the moment from season 5’s iSpy where Phil greets Jay happily and Jay replies with “I’m just here to pick up Manny, no need for a whole thing” - after which we cut to a talking head of Jay reflecting: “I don’t know why I do that to him, the guy’s always so happy to see me!”. Absolutely brilliant. Secondly, we have this 10/10 dialogue from season 3’s Door to Door:
Phil: “Okay, huddle up everybody. Your mother’s right - she’s the quarterback of this family, and we need to protect her like Blind Side did”
Luke: “She just said the mom was Blind Side”
Phil: “Well, she’s confused. Blind Side was the Black kid who played tight end”
Alex: “Offensive line”
Phil: “Sorry, African-American kid”
Anyway, here come the actual honorable mentions, followed by the actual list!
“What’s the plan, Phil?” -Claire Dunphy as Phil tries to stop a car rolling away by jumping on the hood (The Old Wagon, Season 2 Episode 1)
“I don’t know, we just walk around and jump off stuff” -Luke Dunphy on being a kid (Bad Hair Day, Season 4 Episode 16)
“I bet she knew her way around the pole. Eh, should’ve quit after ‘nipple’…how does Leno do it night after night?” -Jay Pritchett being Jay Pritchett (Flip Flop, Season 4 Episode 20)
“He’s a weird man - he’s like Phil except I have to pay for him!” -Jay Pritchett on Andy (The Help, Season 5 Episode 6)
“Didn’t have to, the costume hid it quite nicely” -Cameron Tucker, discussing how he played both the Maid and the Friar in a Robin Hood production, in response to Phil asking “Tuck?” (Crazy Train, Season 7 Episode 21)
10. “The Downton Abbey marathon?” -Jay Pritchett (Rash Decisions, Season 6 Episode 13)
As a response to Manny claiming that he was “tired from the marathon”, this line is a hilarious statement that speaks volumes about both characters - Manny’s silly and artsy persona, as well as Jay’s old-fashioned attitude about his son’s interests and lack of real life experience, are both condensed with perfection into this comeback. Also, Ed O’Neill’s exasperated delivery of the line and his comedic timing are hysterically good.
9. “The Jay Pritchett? I don’t get it - they named you after a sandwich?” -Gloria Delgado-Pritchett (Tableau Vivant, Season 3 Episode 23)
While Gloria isn’t quite my #1 favorite character from the show, she is definitely one of the funniest ones - as proved by the fact that she appears a record four times on today’s list. Everyone in the cast has their strengths: Ty Burrell / Phil is the best at physical comedy and facial expressions, Jesse Tyler Ferguson / Mitch is the best at relatable moments and sarcastic comments, Julie Bowen / Claire is the understated glue of the cast and the beating heart of the show, and I will die on the hill that Sarah Hyland / Haley has the very best comedic timing. But the very best at hilarious deliveries of individual lines, making the absolute most out of the line written in the script - that one goes to Sofia Vergara as Gloria, and it’s really no contest.
This is a brilliant example - the line itself is already pretty damn funny, in a simple yet effective way, but it’s Vergara’s baffled delivery that lifts it all the way to the top ten. Whether the confusion at the order of things comes from Gloria’s language barrier or from a more general lack of logical thinking in the moment, the misunderstanding itself makes for a great joke and Vergara’s delivery truly finds its full potential.
8. “Get the f**k out of here, Manny!” -Lily Tucker-Pritchett (Red Alert, Season 10 Episode 16)
This line is great on so many levels - there's the primitive humor of there being something inexplicably funny in a character obviously saying the F-word and it being bleeped on a network show, as well as the fact that it's a child saying it. Then there's the line's context in all glorious build-up - Lily is having her first period, all the major female characters are outside the bathroom door trying to help but no one is getting through to her, and that's when Manny arrives on the scene and thinks that he can speak to the young girl better than any of the women - hence this line.
The line also gains extra points because it feels like a larger payoff - as much as I adore the Manny from the early seasons, they wrote him into somewhat of an arrogant creep in the later seasons, and after multiple episodes of obnoxious behavior, this line is such a well-earned moment of putting the guy in his place.
7. “She faced her fears, and it didn’t kill her! What killed her two weeks later was a bus” -Gloria Delgado-Pritchett (Hit and Run, Season 3 Episode 5)
Time for more Gloria! Again, the joke itself is pretty decent writing-wise, and would make for a solid laugh even when delivered by a lesser actor. But it's Vergara's exquisite skill with comedic line deliveries that make this into a dynamite joke that'll have you (or at least me) laughing out loud every time. The turn from uplifting anecdote to oddly dark twist, contrasted with the excited yet matter-of-fact tone in Gloria's voice, is just pure gold.
6. “God, I hate yard sales!” -Jay Pritchett (Yard Sale, Season 4 Episode 6)
This one feels like it shouldn't be this good, but between the delivery and the comedic timing, it just somehow is. Among the more prominent storylines of the yard sale episode, Jay's subplot follows him being increasingly grumpy while making his negative view on yard sales clear. This intersects with Alex's storyline in the best possible way, as various characters have assumed that her new boyfriend Michael is gay, which prompts him to do some emotional reflection - inside the Delgado-Pritchett house, for some reason.
While we as the viewers know the character by this moment, one has to think about it from Jay's POV - he has escaped the commotion outside into the comfort of his own home, he finds a random young guy standing there, he asks if he can help him, and the guy responds "Yeah - why does everybody think I'm gay?". Jay replies with the iconic line in quesion - and whether he's saying it to Michael, to himself, to absolutely no one or to the mockumentary cameras, the exclamation makes for pure hilarity.
5. “No no no, arms down says I’m white and I’m sorry, arms up means you don’t know what I am” -Phil Dunphy (Baby on Board, Season 3 Episode 24)
Unlike most of the quotes on today's list, this one doesn't need the context of the full episode or any major storyline in order to be as funny as it is - it's just a random-ass moment of absolute comedic perfection. I still don't know exactly what Phil was going for with this specific piece of dance instructions to Alex - but that's the wonder of the joke.
It makes so little sense that it'll make you laugh out of sheer confusion, but it also makes perfect sense in relation to Phil as a character - like, if you've seen enough of the show to understand what Phil is all about, you do kind of see the half-baked logic in this line from his POV. In any case, it's a well-delivered, utterly bewildering and highly memorable line.
4. “Aye, don’t even say that word! Where I come from it is considered very back luck when your house burns down” -Gloria Delgado-Pritchett (After the Fire, Season 3 Episode 8)
Once again - nobody lifts a slightly above-average line into the stuff of legends like Sofia Vergara in her role of a lifetime. This response to someone mentioning the recent fire that burned down the neighbors' house is just pure gold, both in terms of writing but especially Vergara's delivery.
The twist on Gloria's usual wacky Colombia stories is brilliant, with the underlying implication being that she doesn't think someone's house burning down would be a universally bad thing but instead decides to make this about her cultural beliefs. The genius delivery is borderline meta, in how Gloria's clueless tone makes it crystal clear to the audience how silly this thought process is, while still staying in-character and in-genre without going over the top.
3. “ Oh, a barnacle scraper, hot!” -Dylan Marshall (The Escape, Season 9 Episode 21)
One of my all-time favorite joke types in television is this one, often seen in How I Met Your Mother and Brooklyn Nine-Nine: a character will say something weirdly niche or an uncommon interpretation of something, with the viewer laughing at how no one else would think precisely that, but then a totally different character makes the same association (HIMYM's legendary musk ox turd joke comes to mind).
In one of the all-time greatest examples of this joke type, we have the set-up as Haley's ex Andy mentions that his new girlfriend is a "laker girl" - only to clarify that he's not referring to a cheerleader, but rather a professional Great Lakes barnacle scraper. Later in the episode, Haley's other ex Dylan arrives on the scene - and when Andy mentions his laker girl, he replies with "Oh, a barnacle scraper, hot!". It's just the funniest thing in the world that Dylan would know this, and Reid Ewing's delivery is on point.
2. “Manny, you were afraid to light the barbeque, but now your eyebrows have grown back and your salmon is legendary!” -Gloria Delgado-Pritchett (Fears, Season 1 Episode 16)
There is so much to unpack in this line - Gloria's sweet attempt to encourage her son to face his fears, the reference to an utterly bizarre incident we have not seen in the series but is given just the right amount of context for maximum hilarity, and best of all, the fact that Manny's salmon is legendary. Mind you, this is season 1, meaning that Manny is eleven years old at the time. And his salmon is, that's right, legendary. No other Modern Family moment has made as much comedic mileage about Manny's mature, old-soul personality as this one.
1. “The pregnant one brought a stroller” -Jay Pritchett (Phil’s Sexy, Sexy House, Season 7 Episode 7)
A recap for those who don't remember - in the end tag of this fantastic episode, a whole bunch of Gloria's relatives from Colombia arrive as the Delgado-Pritchett house for a visit. Manny asks Jay if this feels like a short visit or a long one, and Jay replies - with an observant, grumpy and bone-dry tone that only Ed O'Neill could pull off to this degree - with the line quoted above.
This, more than any other individual line, highlights the Modern Family writers' ability to make a mundane situation funny by finding just the right dialogue: "Oh, it looks like Gloria's relatives are going to be here for quite a while" is a fairly amusing premise but there's nothing ultra-funny about it, but the writers found the funniest possible way to convey this information. The pregnant one brought a stroller. And the inflection with which Jay speaks the line. Absolute perfection.
Thank you for reading! Tune in next week as I unpack this year's American remake of the 1936 Berlin Olympics by ranking the most, um, unforgettable moments from the 2026 World Cup.
No comments:
Post a Comment