My (b)log has a message for you.
Next week marks the 30th anniversary of my all-time favorite series Twin Peaks (1990-1991; 2017) airing the final episode of its original run. And, since I had time on my hands, I decided to celebrate by ranking all 48 episodes of the original run as well as the return season from 2017. This was quite the job.
SPOILER ALERT: This post is aimed at people who have seen the series, so there are spoilers ahead.
48. The Black Widow (Season 2, Episode 12)
I don't hate the middle part of season 2 (a.k.a. the part where David Lynch wasn't involved in the writing) like many fans do - I find the concept of following the characters after the point where a series would've usually ended (Season 2 episode 9) quite fascinating and out-of-the-box. That being said, those episodes are significantly weaker than most of the series, as Lynch's absence is especially notable in episodes like this one - I usually love the more absurd storylines in Twin Peaks, but stuff like Nadine (Wendy Robie) joining the school wrestling team is too ridiculous even for me.
47. Slaves and Masters (Season 2, Episode 15)
Another episode from the second season's middle slump. The episode rises above the previously mentioned one due to the big reveal that Josie Packard (Joan Chen) was the one who shot Dale Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan) in the season 1 finale. Other than that, the episode is mainly focused on the weaker storylines from the time when Lynch was missing in action.
46. Masked Ball (Season 2, Episode 11)
Between James's (James Marshall) pointless leaving-town-subplot and Nadine's insomnia hijinks, this episode is mostly quite forgettable. It is however salvaged by the introduction of wonderful recurring character Denise (David Duchovny), which is surprisingly wholesome - not many TV shows in 1990 were willing to include a trans character, especially one who isn't the butt of a joke but rather a positive representation of a vastly under-represented community. Peaks truly was ahead of its time.
45. Wounds and Scars (Season 2, Episode 17)
Largely considered to be the last episode of the season 2 slump, right before the series got a whole lot better towards the end, Wounds And Scars is a mixed bag. On one hand, many of the problems from the previous episodes are still present. But on the other hand, we begin our build-up towards season 2's fantastic ending as we're introduced to Cooper's love interest Annie (Heather Graham), and Michael Ontkean provides his best performance in the role of Harry Truman, as he mourns in the aftermath of his secret lover Josie's death.
44. Laura Is the One (The Return, Episode 10)
One of the very few episodes from 2017's The Return that aren't absolutely amazing. Laura is the One isn't bad, but it doesn't have any of the revival season's biggest strengths going on. There are well-directed moments of psychological horror, but overall the episode falls a bit flat, especially when compared to its counterparts in this magnificent season.
43. The Man Behind the Glass (Season 2, Episode 3)
There's nothing super-special about The Man Behind the Glass, but there's nothing especially wrong with it either. It's classic Twin Peaks. There are no legendary moments, but there is a lot of mystery and amusement as the story progresses and builds towards better things. A solid piece in the puzzle, but nothing mind-blowing.
42. Laura's Secret Diary (Season 2, Episode 4)
Many of the aspects from the episode above this one apply to its successor, but Laura's Secret Diary has the bonus of feeling a bit more Lynchian - between the experimental opening sequence and the fascinating mystery dialogue in Leland Palmer's (Ray Wise) storyline, the episode isn't quite as "basic" as its predecessor, while still being a bit forgettable by Twin Peaks standards.
41. Let's Rock (The Return, Episode 12)
This divisive episode from The Return is so polarizing that it even divided my own opinions - I can't decide whether or not I liked the way Audrey (Sherilyn Fenn) was brought back. On one hand, it's fantastic to see the iconic character again after I had lost all hope of seeing her in the revival. On the other hand, the way she's brought back is depressing and a bit too cryptic even for this series. Then again, that was just what Lynch was undoubtedly going for as he wanted to make a statement about fan service. These things are difficult.
40. Double Play (Season 2, Episode 14)
One of the episodes to rise from the infamous season 2 slump to the level of decent Twin Peaks, due to having some very strong elements - with this episode, it's specifically the scene where Cooper opens up to Sheriff Truman about his past with former colleague and present villain Windom Earle (Kenneth Welsh). The scene is very well-acted by MacLachlan, and it furthered my emotional investment in my all-time favorite fictional character even more.
39. Case Files (The Return, Episode 5)
By Twin Peaks: The Return standards, this episode is a bit lame. By television standards, it's pretty awesome. While the episode is a bit too heavy on the Dougie Jones (Kyle MacLachlan) storyline, it does bring some great moments with it, such as Dale Cooper's soul starting to awaken from Jones's body when he hears the word "Coffee" and repeats it in a loving manner. The storyline of Mr. C (Also Kyle MacLachlan) disrupting the prison security system is also quite intriguing.
38. Checkmate (Season 2, Episode 13)
For much of Checkmate's duration, it's a classic slump-era episode, with many low-stakes subplots that have stretched a bit too far. But then it hits us with that double-cliffhanger in the two final scenes that gave me hope for the rest of the season and made me want to see the next episode immediately. Leo Johnson (Eric DaRe) awakening from his coma and Windom Earle announcing that he's in Twin Peaks through a gruesome message are two hellishly creepy and exciting moments to end the episode on.
37. Dispute Between Brothers (Season 2, Episode 10)
On one hand, I shouldn't like this episode because it is responsible for beginning season 2's string of very below-average episodes. On the other hand, the problems of "the slump" aren't evident yet at this point, and I found the direction that the series took to be extremely cool at first. The season (and series) could've ended on the ultra-climactic previous episode, but instead they kept going. We follow the aftermath of Leland Palmer's reveal as the killer (sort of) and his subsequent death, and we see a lot of stuff we'd never see in another series (the characters simply chilling and going on with their lives after the main story is done for the time being). I have to give points to this episode for its sheer creativity.
36. On the Wings of Love (Season 2, Episode 18)
The final five episodes of season 2 are pretty great, with the slump being over and each episode being better than the last. This begins with On the Wings of Love, a much-needed breath of fresh air. Cooper's romance with Annie starts to take off, leading to some very wholesome moments, but the larger mysteries of the series also start to rear their head as Cooper and the Sheriff's Department explore the strange Owl Cave, thus raising the story's stakes back up to the proper level leading towards the end of the season.
35. The Condemned Woman (Season 2, Episode 16)
The hands-down best episode from the subpar batch of episodes #10 - #17 in season 2. While it does suffer from the same issues as its counterparts (seriously, there are many uninteresting subplots going on at this point), it gains a lot from featuring the well-built climax to Josie Packard's storyline. While she wasn't the most likable character, her death is quite heartbreaking, if only because the viewer knows how much the very likable Sheriff Truman cared for her. The psychedelic doorknob imagery at the end of the episode is also the most Lynchian thing to come from the episodes that weren't written by Lynch.
34. The One-Armed Man (Season 1, Episode 5)
The least good episode of the short but sweet first season is ranked this high, proving just how solid the debut season is. While it has the least amount of addictive Lynchian psychedelia and legendary moments in any season 1 episode, it still has its share - the epic and larger-than-life lore concerning one-armed shoe salesman MIKE (Al Strobel) and his evil counterpart BOB (Frank Silva) deepens, Lynch's deconstruction of the soap opera genre escalates, and most important of all, we get the first appearance of the one of the show's greatest characters - the hard-of-hearing FBI boss Gordon Cole, played by David Lynch himself.
33. Don't Die (The Return, Episode 6)
For the most part, this is one of those early The Return episodes that are so focused on gradually building up the various storylines and mysteries that it feels disjointed and hard-to-follow (this is hardly a complaint, as the payoffs this storytelling leads to are so amazing that it's completely worth it). But one thing really makes Don't Die stand out: we meet Diane (Laura Dern) for the first time. It feels epic to actually see the person who Cooper was always talking to throughout the show's original run, and it's made all the more grandiose by the fact that Lynch's frequent collaborator (and one of my favorite actresses) Laura Dern is playing the part.
32. Variations on Relations (Season 2, Episode 19)
The fourth-last episode of season 2 hits an impressive balance. On one hand, it builds up towards the original run's climax brilliantly, as various characters are deciphering various mysteries from Catherine Martell's (Piper Laurie) puzzle box to the strange symbols in Owl Cave. On the other hand, this is our last blast of pure fun before the last episodes got dark and intense. Gordon Cole flirting with Shelly (Mädchen Amick) in the Double R Diner is one of the funniest and sweetest scenes in television history, and something desperately needed to balance out the incoming darkness.
31. Demons (Season 2, Episode 6)
This is "calm before the storm" personified. The episode after this one would go on to reveal Laura Palmer's killer and change television as we know it for good. The feeling of "Something big is about to happen" is not only present throughout episode 7 of the second season, but already in the previous one, Demons. The scene where MIKE talks to Cooper and company about BOB is one of the creepiest and most otherwordly-feeling moments in the series, as the lore of the show's supernatural side feels more fascinating than ever. Also, there are some delicious Gordon Cole moments.
30. This Is the Chair (The Return, Episode 9)
The storyline where Bobby Briggs (Dana Ashbrook), Frank Truman (Robert Forster) and Hawk (Michael Horse) follow a trail of clues left behind by Bobby's late father Major Garland Briggs (Don S. Davis), is just so extremely cool. It's one of those Twin Peaks storylines where you simply can't explain what is happening and how, but you can't wait to see where it takes the story and just have to appreciate David Lynch for coming up with plots that no one else could create.
29. The Orchid's Curse (Season 2, Episode 5)
"Diane, I am now upside down" is one of the funniest quotes from the extremely quotable Dale Cooper. Furthermore, this episode is the closest thing that Twin Peaks has to an awesome episode from a more normal TV show. The Orchid's Curse isn't all that psychedelic or artistic, but it's an intense and action-packed adventure. The main storyline is that of Cooper and the Sheriff's department rescuing Audrey from One-Eyed Jack's, and it's very exciting to follow. Hawk even gets his big moment of heroism as he defuses a dire situation at the last minute.
28. What Story is That, Charlie? (The Return, Episode 13)
The Return's main villain, Mr. C (also known as Cooper's evil doppelgänger who is possessed by BOB) arm-wrestling a gang leader in order to get vital information is just so David Lynch. It's like a video game side-quest if video games were strange fever dreams. Also, The Return's element of ending each episode with a musical performance at The Roadhouse gets its most epic usage, as the episode ends with the character James Hurley performing the same song he performed to Donna (Lara Flynn Boyle) and Maddy (Sheryl Lee) back during the show's original run. It's a move of sheer mad genius by David Lynch, and something I had hoped would happen but never dared to believe until I saw it for myself.
27. Realization Time (Season 1, Episode 7)
"Harry, I'm gonna let you in on a little secret. Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don't plan it, don't wait for it, just let it happen. It can be a new shirt at the men's store, a catnap in your office chair or two cups of good, hot, black coffee"
Words to live by, Agent Cooper. In addition to this profound wisdom, the second-last episode of season 1 contains a lot of exciting build-up towards the eventful season finale.
26. There's a Body All Right (The Return, Episode 7)
This episode is the point when things start to make sense - as much as they can in the context of Twin Peaks: The Return. For the first six episodes, the different storylines felt extremely disjointed and unconnected, but in this episode, we start to realize the big picture as some explanations are given (in a cryptic, Lynchian way of course) and story threads begin to connect with one another. Gordon Cole, Diane and Albert (Miguel Ferrer) confronting Mr. C in the prison is an especially spine-chilling moment.
25. Coma (Season 2, Episode 2)
While being the co-creator and writer of the whole series, David Lynch only directed six episodes from the show's original run himself (in The Return, he directed all 18 episodes, which is a big part of why The Return is so magnificent). All six Lynch-directed episodes from the first two seasons are pretty great, thus explaining why even the least-good one is so high on my list. Much of the episode feels like standard early Peaks but with an especially mysterious and epic atmosphere, due to Lynch's expert directing. The highlight of the episode is Major Briggs giving Cooper a cryptic message interpreted from deep space probes, which furthers the "The owls are not what they seem" mystery.
24. Rest in Pain (Season 1, Episode 4)
This episode contains great examples of the Twin Peaks holy trinity - there's epic out-of-this-world lore (we find out about the "presence in the woods" and the Bookhouse Boys who keep an eye on it), wild emotionality (Bobby gives a gripping speech at Laura Palmer's funeral) and absurd humor (Cooper has an interaction with a llama). It's all pretty great.
23. Drive with a Dead Girl (Season 2, Episode 8)
Twin Peaks is a lot more than a mere crime drama - but for the crime drama side of the show, it doesn't get much better than Drive with a Dead Girl. Leland Palmer (possessed by BOB) had been revealed as the killer in the previous episode, and would get caught in the next one. Sandwiched between those two classics is this intense episode, where Leland struggles to hide evidence while Cooper and the Sheriff's department start to get closer to the truth. A truly nail-biting piece of the story.
22. Cooper's Dreams (Season 1, Episode 6)
There's so much season 1 madness going on in Cooper's Dreams. Cooper interviews the Log Lady (Catherine E. Coulson), truly one of the show's most fascinating and mysterious characters. Meanwhile, the build-up to the season finale begins as Audrey spies on her father Ben (Richard Beymer) and gets closer to the truth while James, Maddy and Donna start to conduct their own investigation. Shelly also gets one of her greatest moments, as she finally fights back against her abusive husband Leo.
21. The Path to the Black Lodge (Season 2, Episode 20)
Things really start to hit the fan in the third-last episode of the original run. Windom Earle cements himself as one of the show's greatest villains, as he captures Major Briggs and interrogates him about the Owl Cave paintings, revealing much of his mysterious endgame. Meanwhile, the supernatural side of the series becomes more fascinating than ever, as we see the entrance to the much-anticipated Black Lodge, as well as BOB's terrifying return. And so, the table for the last two episodes is set with perfection.
20. We Are Like the Dreamer (The Return, Episode 14)
Twin Peaks on steroids. This memorable episode of The Return manages to cram a lot of amazing stuff into its duration, such as Andy (Harry Goaz) stumbling onto a portal to a place that may or may not be the fabled White Lodge, Gordon Cole having a "Monica Bellucci dream" where the actress plays herself and gives the FBI director a cryptic clue, and the FBI making a big breakthrough in the search for the real Dale Cooper as well as his evil doppelgänger. Man, I love this series.
19. There's Fire Where You Are Going (The Return, Episode 11)
Yet another home run from The Return, this episode is David Lynch at his Lynchiest with all its shenanigans. We get a perfect balance of mind-bending fantasy (Gordon Cole encounters the woodsmen and a portal of theirs), unique and well-directed sequences (the long and uncomfortable shooting scene at the Double R Diner is something only Lynch could do), emotion (The Log Lady's phone call with Hawk is bittersweet) and payoffs full of strange humor (Dougie Jones is about to be killed until the killers find that he has cherry pie and decide to befriend him). Surrealism at its finest.
18. Traces to Nowhere (Season 1, Episode 2)
The second-ever episode of Twin Peaks is a collection of classic moments. The creepier side of the series cements itself in the brilliant sequence where we see BOB for the first time through a reflection in Sarah Palmer's (Grace Zabriskie) vision, but a majority of the episode feels cozy and warm. Angelo Badalamenti's score is heartfelt, and the show's signature atmosphere starts to feel like home. Pete Martell (played by Lynch's go-to character actor Jack Nance) finding a fish in his percolator is undoubtedly one of the most classic examples of Twin Peaks's unique humor. The pilot episode made me fall in love with the series, but this episode proved that it was no mistake.
17. Call for Help (The Return, Episode 3)
The first four episodes of The Return are an ingeniously built puzzle box - you can't quite figure out what's going on, but Lynch leaves so many intriguing clues and addictive story threads in the air that you can't wait to see what's next and how it all will unravel. This is evident as ever in Call for Help, where we are introduced to the notorious Dougie Jones storyline through a bat-shit insane storyline where Cooper seemingly travels between worlds via a purple sea and outer space (Lynch does a brilliant job with the surreal imagery as always). We also see Gordon Cole and Albert Rosenfield for the first time since the original run, which is a warm blast of nostalgia to balance out the weirdness.
16. Miss Twin Peaks (Season 2, Episode 21)
And so we arrive at the penultimate episode of the show's original run. It isn't the most psychedelic, artistic or magical episode of Peaks, but it gains its impressive ranking due to being such a perfect build-up for the finale. Storylines built across several previous episodes start to escalate as season 2's endgame becomes clear: Windom Earle kidnaps Cooper's love interest Annie with the intention of taking her to the Black Lodge. This is one hell of a cliffhanger, and it is executed in a grim and engaging manner. Various subplots also begin to unravel towards their ultimate climax, and the storyline of Andy figuring out the path to the Black Lodge is equal parts amusing and heartfelt.
15. The Stars Turn and a Time Presents Itself (The Return, Episode 2)
After the first episode of The Return confused viewers with its strange and seemingly unconnected narratives, the second episode thankfully provided some answers and clarity. I'm obviously kidding, as episode 2 took the Lynchian step of only furthering the mystery and upping the psychedelia to a maximum. While the episode has moments of humane warmth (such as seeing familiar faces like Shelly and James 25 years after we last saw them), the main focus is in the visually artistic and narratively mind-bending Dale Cooper storyline, as he escapes the Black Lodge after some seriously messed-up encounters. It's all very Lynchian, and quite beautiful in its own way.
14. ...Brings Back Some Memories (The Return, Episode 4)
Bobby Briggs is undoubtedly the most improved TV character of all time. While he had his moments in the original run of the series, he was one of the most annoying and least interesting major characters for a lot of the time, as his douchebag energy and whiny behavior often went too far. In the fourth episode of the revival, we meet a Bobby Briggs who you can hardly recognize as the same man: a gritty and seasoned police officer, with a tough-guy energy but a lot of heart underneath. Briggs's return and improvement was a major win, and the rest of this episode is pretty great as well (whoever decided to cast Michael Cera as Andy & Lucy's (Kimmy Robertson) son deserves a medal).
13. May the Giant Be with You (Season 2, Episode 1)
After the first season ended on eight different cliffhangers (more on that spectacle later), season 2 opened with a bang. All of the cliffhangers are followed up on in a fascinating manner, as we follow the aftermath of the sawmill burning, Cooper getting shot and various other events. The episode has some of the show's most beautiful and emotional moments (such as Ed (Everett McGill) opening up about his love life in a touching monologue), but there is also plenty of room for bizarre Lynch material, as the season premiere features the iconic scene of The Giant (Carel Struycken) giving three cryptic clues to Cooper, including the infamous "The owls are not what they seem".
12. Zen, or the Skill to Catch a Killer (Season 1, Episode 3)
After the two first episodes got me hooked, the third one upped the ante on the Lynchian surrealism and experimental creativity, convincing me that I was watching the possibly greatest television series ever made. The episode is filled with legendary moments, such as Cooper explaining his unusual methods by giving a history lesson on Tibet. The main reason for the episode's status as one of the best is the ending sequence, where Cooper has a bizarre dream that serves as our introduction to the Red Room. Between the presence of otherwordly characters like The Man From Another Place (Michael J. Anderson) and the one-armed MIKE, the backwards-talking sequences, Angelo Badalamenti's trance-like score and the creepy "Fire walk with me" poem, this scene is one of television's most famous sequences for a good reason.
11. There's Some Fear in Letting Go (The Return, Episode 15)
Hands-down one of the most emotional TV episodes ever made. First of all, the episode features the final call between Hawk and The Log Lady, after which she passes away - this is especially moving because the actress who played the role, Catherine Coulson, passed away before The Return aired. The episode is a tribute to her, albeit with a Lynchian twist - while the first episode of the season was dedicated to Coulson, this episode is dedicated to Margaret Lanterman - the real name of the fictional Log Lady character.
Another part of the episode also had me in tears; after defying any sort of conventional fan service and convincing viewers that nothing in the story would go quite as they hoped, Lynch tugged at our heartstrings with a beautiful and thoroughly unexpected payoff - Ed and Norma actually end up together. Their love story had been real and sweet throughout the series, but they had faced so many obstacles that all hope of them getting a happy ending seemed lost - until Lynch became a romantic if just for one magnificent scene, which serves as a perfect send-off for those two characters who deserved the best and got what they deserved.
10. Northwest Passage (Season 1, Episode 1)
The pilot of Twin Peaks is undoubtedly one of the greatest TV pilots ever made. In the 94-minute runtime, we're introduced to the unique town of Twin Peaks, and the show's signature blend of soap opera, philosophical rumination of "What even is a soap opera?", murder mystery, slapstick comedy, exploration of small-town America, supernatural fantasy lore, avant-garde painting come to life and psychedelic fever dream. It features truly unforgettable moments, such as Leland Palmer hearing about her daughter's death and breaking down in tears while Angelo Badalamenti's bittersweet soundtrack wrenches one's heart, and the greatest introduction of a television character of all time, as Dale Cooper rolls into town while recording a message for Diane that immediately made the world fall in love with the guy.
9. My Log Has a Message for You (The Return, Episode 1)
The first episode of The Return barely beats out the first episode of the original run - to fully explain why I appreciate this strange episode so much, I'd need to write an essay or perhaps a series of essays, but I'll try to boil it down to the basics. The balance between nostalgia and playing with nostalgia (throughout The Return, but most of all in this episode) is a work of absolute perfection. It feels extremely different from the old Twin Peaks, which is a smart move as Lynch doesn't want to go for easy fan-service but rather create something unexpected and original - but because a majority of the episode feels so thoroughly different, those few moments that do feel like classic Twin Peaks feel like huge payoff.
I smiled just the widest smile, when over halfway through the episode we heard Angelo Badalamenti's original main theme and saw the familiar view of Twin Peaks after spending a majority of the episode in different locations with different atmospheres. An epic beginning to one of the greatest television seasons ever made.
8. The Last Evening (Season 1, Episode 8)
What's cooler than ending a season on a cliffhanger? Ending a season on eight different cliffhangers, each one more huge than the last. After a lot of build-up on various addictive storylines, the season finale doesn't conclude said stories but rather deepens them into an even further state of intrigue and leaves them wide open - the classic Lynchian move of answering questions by creating more questions.
Packard Sawmill is burned, leaving the fate of Shelly, Catherine and Pete wide open. James is arrested for cocaine possession after Bobby frames him. Audrey goes undercover in a brothel, only to find out to her horror that her first client is her father. Dale Cooper is shot. That's just a few of the cliffhangers in question - this episode is beyond insane, and will leave you with an unprecedented urge to see the next one as soon as possible.
7. Arbitrary Law (Season 2, Episode 9)
The one where Cooper figures out who killed Laura Palmer. Just two episodes after the audience found out that Leland Palmer (possessed by the evil entity BOB) had killed his daughter, television's best FBI agent proved not to be far behind. In what is easily one of the greatest scenes in television history, Dale Cooper gathers all major players involved in the investigation at the Roadhouse and figures out the missing pieces.
If you're expecting a Sherlock Holmes -style reveal where the detective slowly uncovers the facts and thus the logic of the killer, remember what a surreal series this is and think again. To the backdrop of an intense soundscape and the atmosphere of lights flickering like crazy, Cooper is able to tap into the part of his prophetic dream that he couldn't reach beforehand, where Laura Palmer herself tells him who killed her. After this, Leland is arrested and he dies in his cell, with the last scenes feeling so climactic that this absolutely feels like a series finale - which is why it's funny as hell that they just kept going after this with a series of various low-stakes storylines.
6. The Past Dictates the Future (The Return, Episode 17)
Speaking of climactic episodes, this is as close as the Twin Peaks story ever got to a traditional climax. Sure, it's Twin Peaks, so there's plenty of cryptic imagery and unconventional narrative structure to go around, but there's also an impressive amount of story threads actually coming together.
It's amazing to see the main cast all together in the same place - after 16 episodes of Gordon Cole and company travelling around the country, Cooper's soul being stuck in Dougie Jones's body and only a few major characters residing in the title town, this episode saw Cooper, his FBI allies and the major Twin Peaks residents all coming together at the Sheriff's Department to defeat the show's main villain BOB. Or the evil force known as "Jowday" that BOB originated from. Or Cooper's evil doppelgänger who was possessed by BOB. Or the orb that BOB is in. It's all very unclear. Still, this second-last episode of The Return feels like the actual series finale, with Episode 18 being more of a bizarre epilogue (more on that later).
5. Gotta Light? (The Return, Episode 8)
And so we arrive at the hands-down weirdest, strangest, most bizarre episode of television (or piece of any media) that I have ever seen. The way I see it, there are five levels to how strange and experimental David Lynch's works are - level 1 are the select few "mainstream" movies like The Straight Story (1999) and The Elephant Man (1980), level 2 is the run-of-the mill weirdness of Wild At Heart (1990) and the first 2 seasons of Twin Peaks, level 3 is the extreme weirdness of Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me (1992) and Mulholland Drive (2001), level 4 is the absolute batshit insanity of Eraserhead (1977) and the other 17 episodes of Twin Peaks: The Return - and level 5 is reserved only for this one episode of The Return, which is beyond all else.
I could write a series of essays, or perhaps a book, just trying to analyze this episode. I won't even get into what I think the episode means in this post, because there is no way to explain my thoughts briefly. What I will say that the visual imagery alone earns Gotta Light? a spot in the TV hall of fame, as Lynch does a breathtaking job creating beautiful and unforgettable scenes that could be framed on one's wall - whether it's the slow zoom into the atomic explosion, the epic majesty of the lighthouse amidst the purple waves or The Woodsman (Played by Abraham Lincoln impersonator Robert Broski because why the hell not) broadcasting his poem at a radio station, everything looks majestic. If you get into the episode's symbolic meanings relating to Twin Peaks lore, it all gets a whole lot more amazing from there. A true work of experimental art at its finest.
4. What Is Your Name? (The Return, Episode 18)
Many people didn't like the last-ever Twin Peaks episode, and I don't blame them. A series doing a semi-conventional climax and then doing one more episode which is a major curveball into everything isn't something you see every day. But for me, this was the perfect way to wrap the story up (or, more accurately, leave it very much unwrapped). IMDB user tommyhawka reviews the episode with the title "David Lynch ignores a simple conclusion and produces a work of art", while user rwicky19 titled their review "Lynched again - a masterpiece", and those titles sum up my feelings.
The episode is extra-cryptic even for the series at hand, which is why it's a fantastic David Lynch move. This episode is for Twin Peaks what Twin Peaks was for the rest of television - something thoroughly new and different, unexpected and inexplicable. The final scene leaves us with such a well-built mystery that is frustrating in the exactly the right way, that I can't help but tip my hat to Lynch for creating an unimaginable finale that is unlike anything anyone could've seen coming.
3. Lonely Souls (Season 2, Episode 7)
My writer's brain was immediately worried about one thing when I started to watch this murder mystery series - how could its conclusion work? Murder mysteries are often great right up until the point where the killer is revealed, because in most cases, it is somewhat anti-climactic because it is just one of the suspects. I can now say that I thoroughly underestimated the genius of Mr. Lynch when having such thoughts - the madman reveals the killer halfway through season 2, and uses this answer to the mystery to create an even larger mystery. From this episode onward, one realizes that the series was never about "Who killed Laura Palmer?", but something much bigger.
The way the reveal happens is also built with perfection. For a string of many scenes, the feeling that something big is about to happen gets gradually larger and larger - from the point where the Log Lady arrives at the station to tell Cooper that there are owls in the roadhouse and Cooper replies "Something is happening, isn't it?", you get the feeling that something large is indeed going on. By the time that Angelo Badalamenti's emotional soundtrack starts to fuse with the song the band in the Roadhouse is performing, and Cooper has a vision of The Giant telling him "It is happening again", the feeling is huge and impalpable. Then we see Leland being possessed by BOB and killing Maddy Ferguson in one of television's most gruesome, horrifying and well-built sequences. "Shocking" doesn't even begin to describe it.
2. No Knock, No Doorbell (The Return, Episode 16)
First and foremost, Twin Peaks (just like most of Lynch's movies) is about one large theme deep down - the light within the dark. Lynch creates worlds filled with grief and violence, and then creates moments of unspeakable beauty and hope, which feel all the more powerful because of the dark context from which they arise. This is evident in his greatest film Blue Velvet (1986), it's evident throughout the original Twin Peaks run, and it is especially evident in the third-last episode of The Return, where we get the greatest payoff in television history.
Like I've mentioned, Dale Cooper is my favorite television character of all time. Kyle MacLachlan plays the unique role with an unparalleled level of positive energy, optimism and childlike enthusiasm that one can't help but fall in love with. And this is why it's so harrowing to watch MacLachlan's role for the first 15 episodes of The Return - instead of getting the return of the Cooper we know and love, MacLachlan plays a double role as two different characters - one is the evil entity BOB posing as Cooper, and the other is the strange character Dougie Jones who was fused with the real Cooper. But, after a hell of a long wait, this magnificent episode brought about the return of the real Dale Cooper, and it is a thing to behold.
From his first lines after getting up from his hospital bed, the viewer knows that this is the man we've been missing. Angelo Badalamenti's original Twin Peaks theme starts to play as the confused Bushnell Mullins (Don Murray) asks "What about the FBI?", to which Cooper respons "I am the FBI", equipped with a warm smile and a thumbs-up. I've re-watched this masterpiece of a scene multiple times on Youtube, and always end up nodding at the top comment that states "I don't think I'm exaggerating when I say this is the greatest moment in human history".
1. Beyond Life And Death (Season 2, Episode 22)
One of my all-time favorite television episodes for a damn good reason. The final episode of the show's original run meets conventional expectations well enough, as we get multiple emotional moments and great conclusions to characters archs. The cliffhanger ending is one for the ages, and I can only imagine what it was like for people who saw this back in 1991 to wait a full 25 years for the follow-up. I'd also like to point out that the episode literally contains the line "I'll see you again in 25 years", in case it wasn't clear that David Lynch is an actual wizard.
But the foremost reason for this being my favorite episode of my favorite series is everything that goes down in the Black Lodge. This larger-than-life location and its Red Room had been teased brilliantly throughout seasons 1 and 2, as every now and then we'd get a glimpse of what goes on there, always in the context of especially epic and meaningful episodes. It was clear for a long time that the Black Lodge was the epitome of the show's lore and the endgame of where things were going. In this finale, Cooper goes into the Black Lodge in an attempt to save the love of his life, Annie, and everything that happens there is norm-defying, mind-bending and astonishing.
The scenery that Lynch creates is artistic and unlike anything else, from the bizarrre characters and odd architecture to the added atmospheric value of backwards dialogue and Badalamenti's psychedelic soundtrack. This episode taps into the very heart of the experimental strangeness and otherwordly epicness that was the core of Twin Peaks, and it is majestic to see how the story dives deeper and deeper into the Lynchian world of interpretational art, madness, and ultimately beauty and hope. God, I love this series.
Thank you for reading - especially if someone took the time to actually read the whole thing, I hugely appreciate it. I'll be back next week with a slightly less ambitious blog - a ranking of the 10 likeliest countries to win the 2021 UEFA European Championship. Hey, it's an event broadcast on television, so it's not "off-topic" for a blog about movies and TV!