Next Monday is President's Day, the national observance celebrating the proud and untarnished office of President of the United States.
Oh, right, it's not 2015 anymore. Let me rephrase my opening.
Next Monday is President's Day, the national observance celebrating the fantastic joke of an office (also doubling as a popular activity for senior citizens to keep their minds active) that is the U.S. Presidency.
To celebrate, I've compiled two lists: the top 5 portrayals of real-life U.S. Presidents in cinema and television, as well as the top 5 performances as fictional U.S. Presidents in movies and TV. I hope you enjoy!
#5 in performances as real Presidents: John Cusak as Richard Nixon in The Butler (2013)
"I don't want to say anything negative about that Kennedy boy, I'm sure he's a real nice fellow. But do you really want that spoiled rich son-of-a-bitch fuck to be your next President?"
The intriguing premise of Lee Daniels' The Butler has us follow an African-American butler who serves in the White House across multiple decades, and eight presidencies. Any number of performances from this film could've made it onto today's list - Robin Williams channels the stature of Eisenhower, James Marsden finds the proper inspiration and charm for the role of Kennedy, Liev Schreiber is as funny as he is accurate in the role of Lyndon Johnson, and oddness of the casting decision aside, Alan Rickman does a decent Ronald Reagan.
But the one I went with is John Cusak as the crook himself - Richard M. Nixon (the 'M' stands for Misdemeanors). We first meet him when he is serving as Eisenhower's Vice President, and immediately there's an ominous vibe to him. I do respect Cusak for keeping the role humane, though: Nixon is often portrayed in movies and TV as an overblown caricature, and while I do enjoy these parodies as a massive Nixon hater, I also appreciate this film's more realistic take on the admittedly complicated man that ol' Dick was.
#5 in performances as fictional Presidents: Kevin Kline as President William Harrison Mitchell (and as Dave) in Dave (1993)
"You are a very handsome man"
"Thank you, Mr. President"
Sure, Kevin Kline spends quite little time actually playing fictional President Bill Mitchell in this delightful "watch it on a Sunday night or an airplane" type of film, and most of the time playing regular citizen and Presidential lookalike Dave Kovic. But, the film's plot centers on Dave having to pretend to be the President for the time being after the real POTUS had a stroke while having sex with an aide (I think that the film's release in the first years of the Clinton Presidency is top-tier comedic timing). So one could argue that Kevin Kline spends most of the film playing the part of a guy who is playing the part of the U.S. President.
Kline does a fine job with his double role, dealing with the film's mistaken identity -hijinks with humor and heart.
#4 in real Presidents: Alec Baldwin as Donald Trump in Saturday Night Live (1975-Present)
"Great to see a young Trump supporter!"
"Oh, thank you, thank you Mr. President!"
"And where are you from, son - New Mexico?"
"ISIS! Yeah, I was a prisoner in Syria until last week when you freed me, so uh, I just wanted to say thank you for bringing jobs back. To ISIS. And I promise that I will make ISIS great again! Woo!"
"Terrific, what a great guy, ISIS is back in a big, big way folks, and we love that, don't we?"
One day, we'll get a proper movie adaptation of the Trump era. It will either be a thrilling Aaron Sorkin drama going deep into the inner workings of the Trump administration, or a psychedelic and disturbing David Lynch arthouse look at just how surreal it all was. Either way, it'll win ten Oscars and probably be the best film of all time.
For the time being, my favorite performance of the Donald J. Trump role (the 'J' stands for Jackass) has been Alec Baldwin's hysterically over-the-top take on Saturday Night Live. Sure, the show's current Trump (James Austin Johnson) is more accurate, but comedic talent plays a big part in parody performances, and no one beats Baldwin's Trump impersonation in pure amount of laughter caused.
#4 in fictional Presidents: Meryl Streep as President Janie Orlean in Don't Look Up (2021)
"Exactly, 99.78% to be exact"
"Oh, great, okay, so it's not 100%"
"Well, scientists never like to say 100%"
"Call it 70% and let's just move on"
From one over-the-top cartoonish loon to another, Meryl Streep's character in Don't Look Up is so populist, so full of lies, so corrupt and rotten to the core, that it's hard to remember she's one of the fictional ones and not a real product of the American political system. As despicable as President Orlean is, Streep does one hell of a role performance, capturing so much of what is wrong with populist politics.
The character is a brilliant satire of such types, down to the entitled and nepotistic son (while Orlean isn't purely based on Trump but rather a mixture of Trump, Marine Le Pen, Boris Johnson and many others, Jonah Hill is practically just straight-up playing Donald Trump Jr., and the results are fantastic). Definitely one of the worst U.S. Presidents seen in fiction (though still somehow not as bad as a certain real-life one), but admittedly one of the most memorable ones as well.
#3 in real: Robin Williams as Theodore Roosevelt in Night at the Museum (2006) and its sequels
"Some men are born great - others have greatness thrust upon them"
Between Rami Malek's Ahkmenrah, Steve Coogan's Octavius and Robin Williams' take on the 26th President, the acting in this silly film about museum figures coming to life at night is way better than one might expect.
While technically Williams is playing a wax figure that magically came to life and not the actual person who was President, you couldn't tell the difference from the substance of his performance. He does a magnificent job channeling the verbal inspiration and adventurous attitude that Teddy Roosevelt was known for, not to mention the fact that he just really looks the part.
#3 in fictional: Bill Pullman as President Thomas J. Whitmore in Independence Day (1996)
"And should we win the day, the Fourth of July will no longer be known as an American holiday, but as the day the world declared in one voice - we will not go quietly into the night! We will not vanish without a fight! We're going to live on, we're going to survive! TODAY WE CELEBRATE OUR INDEPENDENCE DAY!"
Oh, hell yeah. Combining the very best elements of what America is and what it should be, Bill Pullman kicks ass and takes names in the role of President Thomas J. Whitmore, who is faced with the tough job of leading the country through its first alien invasion. In the era of Trump and Biden, watching this young, vigorous and verbally sharp President feels like a total escapist fantasy, especially as Pullman is such a total badass in the role.
The battle speech is one for the ages, even if Ted Cruz did his very best to ruin it by quoting it while urging a violent mob to overthrow our democracy on January 6th. Man, where are those aliens when you need them?
#2 in real: Bruce Greenwood as John F. Kennedy in Thirteen Days (2000)
"What kind of peace do we seek? I am talking about genuine peace, the kind of peace that makes life on earth worth living. Not merely peace in our time but peace for all time. Our problems are man-made, therefore they can be solved by man"
I know - shocking that the history buff and civil rights enthusiast writing this blog would in fact be a fan of the Kennedys. And being a fan, I greatly appreciate Thirteen Days, which tells the story of the Cuban Missile Crisis and feels like a moving tribute to the Kennedy brothers while staying true to the facts instead of over-glorifying anything or anyone. And just as Steven Culp fills the shoes of Robert Kennedy, while Kevin Costner is a class act as Chief-of-Staff Kenny O'Donnell, I'd still argue that the true star of the show is Bruce Greenwood as President John F. Kennedy (the 'F' stands for 'Fucking legend').
The charm, the idealism, and the passionate drive that make Kennedy one of the all-time greats are on full display - but so are his flaws and his struggles. Greenwood delivers a layered and memorable performance, truly capturing the spirit of the man who kept us from going to World War III.
#2 in fictional: Dennis Haysbert as President David Palmer in 24 (2001-2010; 2014)
"Make no mistake: if we unleash our military power on nations that later prove innocent, it will rank as one of the most despicable sneak attacks in history. Any chance for peace in the Middle East will vanish forever. Even if it'll cost American lives in the future, we must delay this attack until we are certain of our ground"
A few things in the known universe are as massive as the balls on the 24 writers, writing the monologue quoted above in the lord's year 2002, effectively showing a gigantic middle finger to the Bush administration before it was cool. It is also one of the many times when the fictional President David Palmer was an inspiring light of beacon not only in the show's own reality, but also as a trailmap for how real-life Presidents should conduct themselves.
A lot of people, including Barack himself, have given this character's existence in the series (as well as Dennis Haysbert's performance) credit as a sort of precursor to Barack Obama's eventual path to the Presidency. For a long time, racism was so mainstream and prevalent in America that the idea of an African-American President seemed impossible (as late as in the 90's, 2Pac rapped 'We ain't never gonna se a Black President'), and one of the many things contributing to the disruption of this stigma was that millions of Americans saw a Black man as President in this popular and beloved TV series. In addition to helping Americans get used to this visual, Dennis Haysbert's performance throughout his time on the series is absolutely amazing, with President Palmer being a force to be reckoned with and one of the show's most iconic characters.
#1 in real: Christopher Jackson as George Washington in Hamilton
"It's allright, you wanna fight, you've got a hunger
I was just like you when I was younger
Head full of fantasies of dying like a martyr?
Dying is easy, young man, living is harder
I'm being honest
I'm working with a third of what our Congress has promised
We are a powder keg about to explode,
I need someone like you to lighten the load!"
Okay, so techincally the Broadway musical Hamilton doesn't qualify as a movie, but hear me out - technically, it does, as a performance of the musical with its original cast was shot with multiple cameras, edited, and released on Disney Plus as an on-screen way of watching the musical. So, it is enough of a movie to qualify for this list, as I really want to discuss Christopher Jackson's performance as George Washington.
Jackson is quite simply outstanding in this hard-to-live-up-to role. The very essence of the American revolution is captured in his inspiring way of speaking (or singing, or more often than not, rapping, due to the nature of the musical), while his overall demeanor and facial expressions truly rise up to the gravitas of our first Preisdent. Whether it's his intense rapid-fire opening lines in his introductory track Right Hand Man, his touching words of wisdom to the musical's titular protagonist in History Has Its Eyes On You, or his blistering emotional vocals in his tear-jerking farewell track One Last Time, Jackson's performance as the Pride of Mount Vernon is one for the ages.
#1 in fictional: Martin Sheen as President Josiah 'Jed' Bartlet in The West Wing (1999-2006)
"When, after having heard the explosion from the practice facility they ran into the fire to help get people out. Ran into the fire. The streets of heaven are too crowded with angels tonight"
"The ultimate weakness of violence is that it is a descending spiral. Returning violence with violence only multiplies violence, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of light"
"I like your show. I like how you call homosexuality an abomination"
"I don't say homosexuality is an abomination, Mr. President, the Bible does"
"Yes it does, Leviticus"
"18:22"
"Chapter and verse. I wanted to ask you a couple of questions while I had you here. I'm interested in selling my youngest daughter into slavery, as sanctioned in Exodus 21:7. She's a Georgetown sophomore, speaks fluent Italian, always cleared the table when it was her turn. What would a good price for her be? While thinking about that, can I ask another - my Chief-of-Staff Leo McGarry insists on working on the Sabbath. Exodus 35:2 clearly says he should be put to death - am I morally obligated to kill him myself, or is it okay to call the police?"
Yeah, I couldn't settle on just one quote. When watching Aaron Sorkin's masterpiece The West Wing, there are times when it's physically painful to remind oneself that Jed Bartlet isn't President in real life. Oh, how much better off we'd be - always one for ambitious character writing, Sorkin managed to create a character who embodies everything a politician and President should be, while still making him flawed and deeply human in an interesting way instead of being an over-perfect Superman type.
But while Sorkin is responsible for creating the idea of the character, it's the one and only Martin Sheen who truly brings Bartlet alive and makes him into our greatest fictional President (one who I'd argue has done more good for our nation than a few real-life Presidents). Whatever the situation calls for, whether it's Shakespearean chops of dramatic acting, relatable moments of humor and warmth or the delivery of a line in the most inspiring, fist-pump-worthy fashion one can imagine, Sheen is always able to bring it. The scene in the season 2 finale where Bartlet walks through an empty cathedral, addressing God directly and cursing in Latin, is some of the most profound work I've seen across all art forms, and it's just one of many examples where the character proved himself as one of television's best.
If a guy like Bartlet existed in real life, I'd very possibly pull a Josh Lyman (Brad Whitford) and drop whatever is going on in my life at the moment in order to campaign for this person, all fired up about wanting to make sure that his voice gets heard. Thank you, Mr. President.
Thank you for reading! Tune in next week for my annual Black History Month post, this time focusing on my top 10 favorite African-American filmmakers.