Greetings, reader!
Welcome to the fourth post of my 10-week dive into the world of movie franchises and their various instalments. Today I'm ranking the very best fourth movies in different franchises. It was the oddest list to make thus far, as I noticed that in weirdly many franchises, the fourth one ranks quite low - this isn't just because of the overall deterioration where a later sequel is likelier to be worst than an earlier one, as there were more individual gems to be enjoyed in the category of fifth and sixth instalments as there were here. Maybe part fours are just cursed or something. Anyways, it was a fun challenge to compare the below-average instalments of many great franchises to above-par instalments of overall lesser franchises!
Here are my honorable mentions: Annabelle: Creation, Fast & Furious, Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter, Rocky IV, Wonder Woman.
10. Mothra vs. Godzilla (1964)
After the original Godzilla, the sequel Godzilla Raids Again and the vintage monster-mash King Kong Vs. Godzilla, the fourth Godzilla film ever made marked the first instance of the iconic monster being pitted against another creature from Japanese Kaiju lore, having had its own origin story in a solo film (therefore I consider this crossover to be the fourth instalment in the Godzilla franchise and the second instalment in the Mothra franchise).
Wow - even for me, that was a lot of Veikko. Anyways, this is a fantastic old-school monster flick, with exciting lore and visuals that have aged to look cheesy, but are quite something for the time of the film's release. The themes are also poignant, as the plot takes jabs at capitalism and humanity's greedy tendencies in a manner more nuanced than American monster films could ever dream of.
9. Jurassic World (2015)
After the three original Jurassic Park made the franchise's popularity and relevance fade with their varying quality, Colin Trevorrow revived the series with this fresh and nostalgic reboot. Mind you, Jurassic World is not revolutionary or mind-blowing to the slightest, but it does everything a reboot is supposed to do in a thoroughly solid manner.
The balance of callbacks to the original Jurassic Park and introductions of new settings, characters and storylines makes for an end product that feels very "Remember that film you loved in the 90's? Here's everything you liked about it, but in a 2010's style". Naturally it's not nearly as good as the original, but quite a bit better than films #2 and #3. A textbook example of reboots done right, while far from perfection.
8. Ocean's Eight (2018)
Oh, hell yeah. I am so thankful for this female-lead Ocean's Eleven reboot - I was so scared of being unconsciously sexist after I didn't like 2016's Ghostbusters, but this flick confirmed that I have no quarrel with the concept of all-female reboots. The Ghostbusters reboot is just bad cinema. Ocean's Eight is a female-lead reboot done right, and a very overall kick-ass heist flick. Similarly to the case of Jurassic World, this one isn't as good as Ocean's Eleven, but significantly better than Ocean's Twelve and Ocean's Thirteen.
While the cameos and other neat connections to the original Ocean's cast are a delight, the new gang are the stars of the show through and through. Awkwafina and Mindy Kaling provide comic relief, Rihanna and Sarah Paulson provide fun and surprising characters, Helena Bonham Carter and Anne Hathaway add a lot with their effortless star power, and Sandra Bullock and Cate Blanchett are dynamite leading ladies as one can expect. All in all, a heist caper worth checking out!
7. Star Wars: Episode I - A Phantom Menace (1999)
This one was tough to rank. Some people hate it, others have forgiven it or have a nostalgic soft spot for it, and the overall discourse around the Star Wars prequels is fascinating. My own relationship with the prequels is similar to my relatitionship with the post-Sorkin seasons of The West Wing or the Brian Johnson era of AC/DC - it's clearly less good than what came before, but it's still really good.
By Star Wars standards, especially when compared to the original trilogy, Episode I is flawed in many ways. The acting performances vary in quality, the dialogue is sloppy, and some of the attempts at comic relief feel more than a bit forced. That's why The Phantom Menace is only at seventh place, ranked below the fourth instalments of many franchises that wouldn't hold a candle to Star Wars when comparing franchises as a whole.
But, still, the film does a lot right. The Star Wars atmosphere still hits hard, the visuals are great for their time, and there are some unforgettable and epic moments in the mix. So that's why it still belongs on the list, and above quite a few decent-but-not-amazing flicks. Subpar Star Wars is still Star Wars.
6. Captain America: The First Avenger (2011)
Here we have the first Captain America film, which belongs on today's list as it is the fourth movie in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (after Iron Man, Iron Man 2 and Thor). It's the last solo film to be released before the first Avengers flick, and the build-up towards that major event is certainly a part of Captain America: The First Avenger's charm.
But it's a lot more than that: in all its simplicity, this flick has arguably more heart than any other MCU flick. The franchise can be roughly divided into three eras: the early films where they didn't take the universe all that seriously (2008-2014), the golden era where they took the films just seriously enough (2014-2019), and the past-its-prime era where they take the films a bit too seriously (the 2020's). This film is one of the better instances from the first era, as the "not taking it so seriously" feel, which is a weakness in films like Iron Man 2, is most certainly a strength. The film is a blast.
5. Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol (2011)
Mission: Impossible has always been one of those franchises that aren't among my big favorites, but make for solid and moderate enjoyment nonetheless. The first film is pretty awesome, the second one has its moments, the third is a case of J.J. Abrams' directing and Philip Seymour Hoffman's villain making up for the lazy plot - and then we have the franchise's peak with Ghost Protocol.
The dramatic going-rogue plot keeps you guessing and in suspense, director Brad Bird's borderline cartoonish antics are sure to keep the tone entertaining and light enough despite the drama, and the stunts performed by America's favorite scientologist Tom Cruise are almost as crazy as the man himself. And a shoutout to Finland's own Samuli Edelmann for his role as villainous henchman Wistrom!
4. Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005)
Much like the case of Star Wars: Episode I earlier on the list, this is a film that is below-average for the series it belongs to, but still ranks highly due to the franchise's overall level being so solid that even the lesser films are pretty awesome. The Goblet of Fire is my least favorite Potter film (while still better than the Fantastic Beasts films), but let's face it - none of them are bad. It's worse than the others mainly because Mike Newell's directing style feels more general-Hollywood-fantasy and less specifically Harry Potter, especially compared to the franchise's other three directors who all brought something unique to the franchise. But it's still a kick-ass film, with elements from the cast to the score being just as great as always.
And then for my weekly J.K. Rowling rant. What really bugs me is how public she has to be - I'm painfully aware that many people of her generation have unfortunately conservative views on trans rights due to a lack of understanding, and to a degree it's understandable that people who didn't grow up aware of trans issues would take longer to wrap their head around the fact that there's this community of people who just want to live their lives true to themselves and they aren't a danger to anyone. But why couldn't she keep her stupid close-minded views to herself?? Why insist on all these public rants?! Doesn't she realize that thousands of LGBTQ+ youths grew up loving her books, and that it breaks their heart to find out that the author doesn't respect their human rights? So, yeah, I'm really hoping that she'd just shut the f**k up.
3. Thunderball (1965)
Quite a rare occurrence to see the week's James Bond representative ranked higher than the likes of Harry Potter and Star Wars on my blog! But, as far as fourth instalments specifically go, the fourth 007 adventure quite simply has what it takes. In one of Sean Connery's most entertaining outings in the role, we follow a plot that doesn't even try to be believable or conventionally great cinema like the modern Bond flicks, but rather embraces the cheese and makes for an unforgettable and extremely fun spy flick.
From makeshift jetpacks to underwater fight sequences, from exciting settings in the Bahamas to the fantastically over-the-top-villain Emilio Largo (Adolfo Celi) wanting to blow some major cities up with stolen nuclear warheads, Thunderball is a relentless, tongue-in-cheek thrill ride. A stone-cold classic with peak Sean Connery charm.
2. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)
I know - this one gets a lot of hate. In my unpopular opinion, the Hobbit movies are actually really good, and people over-hate them for the unforgivable sin that they are not as masterful and perfect as The Lord of the Rings.
Did the 310-page book need to be made into three movies? No, it didn't, I'll admit that much. But does it being split into three films hurt as much as many fellow fantasy nerds claim? No, it does not! Peter Jackson made some exciting choices with these films: it's not just the events of the short book drawn out, but rather a juxtaposition of the White Council plotline which makes sense (while it isn't followed in The Hobbit book, it's based on Tolkien's other in-universe writings and took place at the same time while involving familiar characters, so why not include it?). And fan service like connections to The Lord of the Rings, which I for one enjoyed.
The first Hobbit film (that is therefore the fourth film in the Middle-Earth franchise, and thus on today's list) isn't as much of a masterpiece as the three Lord of the Rings films. But that does not make it bad. The more lighthearted tone is fitting as the Hobbit book is more fun and zany than the heavier Lord of the Rings books, and many of my favorite parts from the first third of the book come to life in a wonderful manner on the big screen. Grow up, haters.
1. Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home (1986)
And so it is that today's winner comes from a thoroughly surprising franchise! Mind you, I'm one of the biggest Star Trek fans I know, but it's widely recognized that this franchise does TV shows better than movies by average, so one wouldn't expect to see one of the Star Trek films topping a list like this one.
While the superiority of Star Trek TV over the franchise's film sequels is certain, as no Trek movies have come close to the greatness of what Deep Space Nine or The Next Generation are at their best, it still needs to be stated that some of the better Trek films do kick their share of ass. And one of them is The Voyage Home.
You wouldn't expect the fourth consecutive movie sequel to the original series, starring the same washed-up cast, directed by one of the main actors, adding comedy to the genre combination of sci/fi and adventure, and having a plot revolving around going back in time to the 1980's to communicate with humpback whales (no, really) to be, um, good. But it is. The fourth Star Trek flick is fun as hell, the chemistry of the main cast and their interactions with side characters met throughout the time travel hijinks are off the charts, and the ending is deliciously satisfying.
Thank you for reading! Tune in next week for the next chapter of this project - the top 10 fifth instalments of movie franchises.