Greetings, reader!
Last week marked the 10-year anniversary of crime drama Dexter's infamously opinion-splitting series finale. While I actually liked the show's polarizing ending quite a bit, it still doesn't make it onto today's list, because there are many shows out there that tied the final knot even better. My four-week dive into the best beginnings and endings in television culminates here, with the list of the greatest-ever series finales from drama TV.
Here are my honorable mentions: All Good Things... (Star Trek: The Next Generation), Felina (Breaking Bad), Hello, Elliot (Mr. Robot), Rest In Peace (The Walking Dead), Saul Gone (Better Call Saul).
10. Prisoners of War (Homeland)
"Greetings from Moscow, Professor"
Homeland was never destined to have a conventional series finale: the series never did neat character archs or thematic morals-of-the-story in such a way that a typical 'send-offs, emotions, poetic bows on things' finale would make any sense. The show's final hour feels very fitting for this particular series, though; the tensions surrounding the final season's major storyline remain high until the last moments, and the conclusion feels sudden yet quite perfect.
After a series of moral dilemmas, backroom deals and betrayals has been executed in order to prevent a full-scale war from starting, a void is left as Saul Berenson's (Mandy Patinkin) longtime Russian asset has been compromised and protagonist Carrie Matheson (Claire Danes) has broken enough laws and crossed enough lines for the greater good that there is no coming back. These two problems solve themselves, however, as the 'two years later' epilogue reveals in a beautifully subtle manner that Carrie has become Saul's new Russian asset. For such a dark and cynical series, this is the closest they could get to a 'happy ending' - it's not exactly sunshine and rainbows, but it feels comforting to know that Carrie is still out there in the show's reality, doing the important work.
9. What Kind of Day Has It Been (The Newsroom)
"Charlie Skinner was crazy. He identified with Don Quixote - an old man with dementia who thought he could save the world from an epidemic on incivility simply by acting like a knight. His religion was decency. He spent a lifetime fighting its enemies. I wish he could be here to learn the name of his successor like I just did - our new boss, the new president of ACN is MacKenzie McHale"
If these were ranked based on whether or not they made me cry, and how much if yes, then the finale of Aaron Sorkin's The Newsroom would be much higher still. Taking place in the aftermath of Charlie Skinner's (Sam Waterston) tragic death at the end of the penultimate episode, this episode wraps the show up surrounding his funeral, while making it crystal clear via speeches and flashbacks just how integral Charlie's character was to the show's story, its themes, and everything the characters stood for. The goofy, idealistic old man, on a crazy but righteous mission to civilize, absolutely was the show - that's why killing him off was so shocking, and why the final episode being more or less a tribute to him felt as appropriate as it felt touching.
The scene where Will McAvoy (Jeff Daniels) jams That's How I Got to Memphis, a song that had special meaning to his deceased friend as revealed in a previous flashback, with Charlie's grandchildren, is one of the most moving and heartwarming scenes out there. Before and after that special moment, storylines and character archs are subtly wrapped up, with the funeral setting making the finale feel less "race against time, high stakes till the end" than most drama finales, and more "sweet, nuanced epilogue". Every character gets a good ending, with the absolute cherry on top being MacKenzie McHale, the only Newsroom character even better than Charlie in my view, poetically becoming the new head of ACN news, with her protegé Jim Harper (John Gallagher Jr.) getting her old job as EP, and Will McAvoy staying on as the anchor America needs but doesn't deserve.
8. The Iron Throne (Game of Thrones)
"It doesn't matter what I do"
"It matters more than anything"
Last week, I defended the over-hated How I Met Your Mother finale, and promised an even hotter take for this week. Well, here it is. Yes, I thoroughly enjoyed the final season and final episode of Game of Thrones - my full thoughts on the subject would warrant a master's thesis worth of information, but here it is in a nutshell. I'll start with a defense against the arguments most often used to criticize the show's ending, and then move on to why I regard it so highly.
First of all, we must adress the fact that showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss were handed an impossible situation: they got the order to start writing the series in the early 2010's, when the A Song of Ice and Fire book series was still underway. Five books out of seven had been released, and author George R. R. Martin okayed for the TV series to launch in 2011, promising that the rest of the books will be finished in time. Well, as of right now, books VI and VII still haven't been finished, so a little over halfway through the series, D&D pretty much had to start improvising, as there was no more source material to adapt from. Fans seem to generally lay the blame 100% on the writers, as if they f**king decided for Martin to not finish the books. I think they were given an impossible situation, and as someone who genuinely enjoyed the final seasons, I think they did an incredible job with it.
The biggest complaint I keep hearing about the final season is that people didn't agree with the direction of the plot - it really grinds my gears that despite the massive-scale visuals, cinematic set design, groundbreaking production values, immensely talented cast, enthralling score and about a thousand other positives, people really have the inexplicably petty opinion that the final season was "total shit" and "1/10" for the reason that they didn't agree with some of the story choices. I for one did like the story, but even if you don't, I'd say that it's massively disrespectful towards everything the series did right to have such a level of hate for season 8 simply because things happened in the story that you wouldn't have liked to happen. Especially when that is what Game of Thrones has always done.
The show, just like the books it was based on, was always one for shocking, expectation-defying plot twists. Throughout the series, people liked it - they liked not knowing what comes next, they liked the shock of Ned Stark (Sean Bean) being beheaded in the first season and King Joffrey (Jack Gleeson) being poisoned at his wedding. In my view, the final season did what the series has always done, but the mentality of the fans had changed. It was a long, two-year wait between seasons 7 and 8, and during that time, the internet was filled to the brim with theories and speculation on how Game of Thrones will end, with everyone having their own clear vision on how things would go down. Suddenly, the fans expect things to go a certain way. People were expecting a neat ending where Jon Snow (Kit Harington) kills the Night King (Vladimir Furdik) and becomes King, not realizing that such a poetic and predictable outcome would go against everything the franchise stands for. So, when the final season did what the series has always done and subverted expectations, fans were all upset that things didn't go the way they had read/written on online forums.
For a concrete example, let's compare two plot twists: the infamous Red Wedding from season 3, and Daenerys' (Emilia Clarke) 'turn to evil' in season 8. Both twists land the similar narrative combination of being shocking yet making sense. The Red Wedding was built subtly enough that you didn't see it coming and thus it shocked everyone, but there was enough background build-up that it made total sense and didn't feel out of the blue. Similarly, the Daenerys twist happens in such a dramatic manner that it certainly feels shocking, yet it's not one bit out of the blue, as previous seasons had laid the groundwork by gradually hinting more and more that she might've inherited the cruelty of her father, the Mad King. At least in my view, the twist makes perfect sense in hindsight as it fits the trajectory of the character. There is little difference between these twists from a storytelling perspective, yet fans adore the first and detest the second. This is because in season 3, the future was still ahead and viewers wanted to be shocked, enjoying the feeling of not knowing what comes next. In season 8, everyone had their own opinion on how the show 'should' end, and therefore an admittedly shocking but honestly well-built plot twist caused a whole bunch of bratty whining.
Watching the series like I did, living every moment and appreciating every shock instead of fantasizing about a perfect ending in my head, the final season as a whole was a very positive viewing experience, and the series finale in particular - while I do on some level hear why people didn't like the Arya (Maisie Williams) / Night King twist or the Daenerys twist earlier in the season, it feels very hard to understand why someone would hate the finale, other than the attitude problem of deciding to hate it before it even aired because the preceding episodes weren't to your liking. Before you get defensive about this point, honestly ask yourself: having formed an opinion of what season 8 was up until then, did you give the final episode a chance? Because I'd argue that when viewed with an open mind, the finale feels so very Game of Thrones, and the character endings make sense to a profound degree.
Bran (Isaac Wright) as King? Yes, definitely yes. Both the Bran scenes of the show and the Bran chapters of the books always felt different from everything else, giving a sense that this character is going to have an extremely important role to play in the endgame, that there is something magical and epic in his character arch. Couple that with the wisdom he gained after merging with the Three-Eyed Raven, and you have a fair and deserving successor to the Iron Throne.
Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) as Hand of the King? Perfection. When you look at his screentime in the series and the amount of his POV chapters in the books, it is clear that Tyrion was one of the most important characters from the beginning, and one of the most heroic ones - Game of Thrones doesn't do traditional hero narratives, but the often flawed Tyrion always came out on top morally (if only barely at times), being a character you can root for. Yet he was no great fighter, and his words were always his weapons. So it feels extremely fitting that he is the genius who talks Jon into doing what he has to do, then talks the council into selecting Bran as King, thus securing the future of the Seven Kingdoms with his wit.
There are many more that I could adress if I hadn't already rambled on for long enough, from Sansa's (Sophie Turner) karma to Arya's adventurous epicness, but the one I'd really like to single out is Jon Snow. His ending is complex, poetic and bittersweet to the degree that I am absolutely baffled that anyone would have a problem with it. The most morally upstanding and conventionally heroic of all the main characters, he ends up facing his toughest and most gripping moral dilemma, which creates much of the tension for the final episode: in order to save the realm, he must kill the woman he loves. Harington plays his role wonderfully, with the insane difficulty of this choice translating into his facial expressions and delivery of lines. Finally, when he does it, he is seen as both hero and villain: half of Westeros wants him crowned King as the rightful heir of House Targaryen, and half wants him executed because he killed their Queen. He can't be either, and so he sets out to live the rest of his life in exile, as a ranger of the Night's Watch. The very place he started his journey, and where he always felt most himself. It is sad to see him succumb to this 'punishment', yet heartwarming to know that on a deeper level he's right at home - a truly powerful and bittersweet ending for his character and for the whole series.
For anyone who still thinks that the final season is crap, please do submit your analytical 10-paragraph arguments to my e-mail veikkohoffman@live.com, and we can have a proper debate.
7. Tomorrow (The West Wing)
"Make me proud, Mr. President"
"I'll do my best, Mr. President"
Similarly to The Newsroom, Aaron Sorkin's even greater masterpiece also saved the biggest emotional stakes and heartbreak of its final season for the episodes nearing the end, especially the Election Day two-parter that might just be the biggest emotional rollercoaster in television. Many of the biggest storylines have been resolved by the time we reach the finale, which poetically follows the transition of power as Jed Bartlet (Martin Sheen) is finally relieved of the Presidency, and Matt Santos (Jimmy Smits) is inaugurated. This promise of a better future sets the legacy of the Bartlet administration and all the work the main characters did across the show's seven seasons in stone, and sends a hellishly strong message to real-life America about how we should be conducting our politics.
But it's not quite as chill as the Newsroom finale - many storylines remain unresolved until the last minutes, chief among them the question of whether or not Bartlet pardons his former employee, loudest critic and better angel Toby Ziegler (Richard Schiff) for his ethically gray actions that many considered treason (I, a pacifist, saw them as nothing short of heroic). The balance between symbolic and nice we-know-what's-going-to-happen bookends and dramatic-till-the-end storylines makes the episode soothing yet compelling. Throw in a fairytale end for Josh (Brad Whitford) and Donna (Janel Moloney), a touching mentor-and-apprentice moment between Bartlet and Charlie Young (Dulé Hill) and a beautiful callback to Leo (John Spencer), a giant we lost both in the show and in real life, and you've got the perfect note to end one of the greatest-ever TV shows on.
6. What Is Your Name? (Twin Peaks)
"What year is this?"
Many people didn't like the last-ever Twin Peaks episode, and I don't blame them. A series doing a semi-conventional climax (at least by the show's standards) and then doing one more episode as a major curveball into everything isn't something you see every day. But for me, this was the perfect way to wrap the story up (or, more accurately, leave it beautifully unwrapped). My feelings about the episode are echoed perfectly by the titles of two IMDB reviews I've read about it: "David Lynch ignores a simple conclusion and produces a work of art", and "Lynched again - a masterpiece".
The words 'Lynched again' feel especially resonant - this episode is to the rest of Twin Peaks what Twin Peaks was to television. When the series first aired, it subverted every expectation on what TV can be, and produced something shockingly different and outstanding. So, instead of making a finale that is weird like the rest of Twin Peaks, Lynch pulled yet another rabbit out of the hat and produced something that was shockingly different and outstanding even relative to what we had come to expect from Twin Peaks.
5. Made In America (The Sopranos)
"Isn't that what you said one time? Try to remember the times that were good?"
When compared to the other shows in the tier of 'TV dramas with the utmost critical acclaim and prestige writing', such as Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones, The Sopranos stands out as less plot-oriented and dramatic than its counterparts. It never was the show that makes you cry, makes you invested across multi-episode storylines, or leaves you guessing with huge cliffhangers. Just like its pilot episode was less "let's get this story started" and more "let's jump into this world as if we're midway through the story", its finale is also less "let's wrap up every storyline with a poetic bow" and more "one more Sopranos episode, feeling like an ordinary episode in many ways, but with the perfect ending scene".
And for this particular series, that was the way to go. Especially because that final scene is one of the greatest moments in television history.
The soundtrack choice of Journey's Don't Stop Believin', the dialogue between the family, the underlying tension, the interpretational and out-of-left-field nature of how it all ends - it's all perfection. The reference to The Godfather is probably the most profound intertextual reference I've seen in television - instead of feeling merely clever and fun like many pop culture references, it feels deep and powerful when it hits you - I also appreciate the implication that if you haven't seen The Godfather, you don't deserve to fully understand the ending of the world-famous mafia series. One for the ages, this ending.
4. What You Leave Behind (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine)
"This may be the last time we're all together. But no matter what the future holds, no matter how far we travel, a part of us - a very important part- will always remain here, on Deep Space Nine"
Deep Space Nine is my favorite of the EIGHT Star Trek shows that have been made, and one of the main reasons is its plot-oriented style and long-term storytelling - in a complete opposite to what I just said about The Sopranos, this show is all about getting invested in the characters while following dramatic and emotionally charged long-term storylines. And there were many of these narrative threads, so many that from a storyteller's perspective, such a grand tale is very challenging to bring to an appropriate close. But the bastards sure pulled it off.
After 173 episodes across 7 seasons, we're treated to a 92-minute powerhouse of emotion that wraps up every characted journey and long-term storyline with majesty. The Dominion War, the ambiguous Prophets narrative, Odo's (Rene Auberjonois) gripping struggle of where he belongs, the fate of Cardassia and its people, the political turmoil on Bajor, Gul Dukat's (Marc Alaimo) situation and the Pah-Wraiths - every imaginable thread is brought to a poetic close.
There were many moments that had me in tears, from the goodbye between Odo and Kira (Nana Visitor) after the former makes his decision, to the montage of friendship moments between best bros Bashir (Alexander Siddig) and O'Brien (Colm Meaney). I also greatly appreciate protagonist Sisko's (Avery Brooks) ending - in perhaps fiction's greatest instance of putting profound symbolic value on an object, his precious baseball had a deep meaning in the ending of season 5, an even deeper purpose in the ending of season 6, and a truly larger-than-life meaning in how the whole series wraps up.
3. The End (Lost)
"She said we were leaving"
"Not leaving, no. Moving on"
One of the most evenly opinion-splitting episodes in television history, the series finale of Lost's six-season run divided fans into those who consider it a masterpiece and those who consider it a total dud. Somewhat unsurprisingly, I belong to the 'love it' end of this particular 'love it or hate it' spectrum.
First of all, the whole "Oh, they were all dead the whole time" interpretation is total BS. It's people with a 'be judgemental, not curious' attitude, not understanding or even wanting to understand the ending, hyping up a dumb false interpretation on the internet in order to come together under making fun of a work of art. No, they were not all dead the whole time. The specific implications of the ending are up for debate, but it's definitely not that.
But more than that, it's just a great and moving final act. Tensions are mounted leading up to the final clash between good and evil on the island, while sideplots are resolved in various emotional moments. There's a special place in my heart for the final scene, and the way it mirrors the very first scene of the series in a poetic manner. The pilot opens with a close-up of Jack (Matthew Fox) opening his eye, after which we following him getting up from his lying stance in the island's jungle, as he gets his bearings while Vincent the dog runs by. Six seasons later, we end with a dying Jack roaming into the same jungle, as Vincent the dog runs by, until he lies down (this all happens to the backdrop of a beautifully bittersweet Michael Giacchino score), and the final shot is a close-up of him closing his eye. A spectacular close.
2. Day 8: 3:00 p.m. - 4:00 p.m. (24)
"When you first came to CTU, I never thought it was going to be you, that was going to cover back all those years. And I know that everything you did today was to try and protect me. I know that. Thank you"
The 24 finale is a masterclass in two elements - keeping the tensions sky-high till the very last minutes, and sending the main character off with a massive emotional charge. The final season, in its endgame, follows a high-stakes storyline of Jack Bauer (Kiefer Sutherland) going rogue and against his government in order to secure proof that will stop a geopolitically world-altering phony peace deal in the name of actual, long-term peace. The final four or five episodes are one of television's finest endgames, with the tension gradually building more and more towards the end, and this is still going on when there are about three minutes left in the final episode's runtime.
After eight 24-episode seasons of getting invested in the story and characters, it feels truly heart-pumping in nature to be guessing and worried about such a large-scale plot up to the very last minutes. When everything is resolved, it doesn't feel rushed despite the powerful resolution taking place in the final minutes. The finale doesn't waste any extra time getting sentimental, but in those last minutes, it efficiently tugs at your heartstrings with Sutherland's emotional delivery of lines and Sean Callery's insanely fitting score. Seriously, the greatest part of this series-best episode might just be how Callery's composition for the final scene mixes elements of the main theme and motifs from memorable moments in past seasons, so that it feels like the whole season flashing before the viewer's eyes.
1. Return 0 (Person of Interest)
"Mr. Reese - John? This wasn't supposed to be the way"
"Sure it is. This is what I do, remember? When you came to me, you gave me a job. A purpose. At first, well...I'd been trying to save the world for so long...saving one life at a time seemed a bit anticlimactic. Then I realized...sometimes one life - if it's the right life - is enough"
The final episode of Jonathan Nolan's criminally underrated Person of Interest tops off a final season that I consider to be the best individual season of television ever made. It all culminates in a profound final hour, where character archs are wrapped up and deep-lying truths about human nature are looked at through a properly mind-bending setting. Acts of love, sacrifice and redemption take place to the backdrop of an appropriately gut-wrenching soundtrack, from CUTS's psychedelically emotional Bunsen Burner to Philip Glass's delicate and swan-song-y Metamorphosis One.
The character journeys of the two main characters, Mr. Finch (Michael Emerson) and Mr. Reese (Jim Caviezel), come to a close that ties into their beginnings in the very first episode. Reese has found his purpose, and his ending is truly bittersweet - after all the trauma he had endured, he could never truly be happy, but given his savior complex, the best possible ending he could get was sacrifing his life in order to save his friends and a greater good. His genuine smile as he stands on the rooftop will break every viewer's heart, yet leave them feeling oddly fulfilled. The flashbacks, shown in a sporadic and cryptic manner throughout the episode, tie into his gripping past, making his ending all the more bittersweet.
And then there's Finch - his backstory with past love interest Grace (Carrie Preston) was always written in such a dark, heartbreaking and cynical manner, that it never felt one bit likely and realistic that they could reunite and have a happy ending. In the show's dramatic context, it just felt like wishful thinking, no matter how hard the viewer feels that Finch would deserve it. So, when the events of the finale do make it possible and we see Finch reuniting with the love of his life, the payoff feels larger than life. This ending is beyond perfect.
Thank you for reading! Tune in next week for my ranking of the films in the Conjuring universe, including the newly released The Nun II.