Gobble gobble!
Last year, I celebrated (t)Hanksgiving by ranking Tom Hanks's greatest performances. This year, on the day of giving thanks, I shall present my list of the greatest television episodes where Thanksgiving is celebrated. I'm including only one episode per series here in the name of variety - otherwise this would pretty much be a list of the Top 10 Friends (1994-2004) Thanksgiving episodes, with one or two episodes from other shows thrown into the mix. Maybe next year I'll do a ranking of all the Friends Thanksgiving specials. Anyways, here's my list!
But first, my honorable mentions: Thanksgiving (Big Mouth, Season 5 Episode 5), The Thanksgiving Decoupling (The Big Bang Theory, Season 7 Episode 9), WUPHF.com (The Office, Season 7 Episode 9).
And, while it doesn't qualify as a TV episode, I'd like to give a special shout-out to the 1973 TV special A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving.
10. Parents (New Girl, Season 2 Episode 8)
"Jess, I'm not done with that! It's 18-dollar granola, hand-made!"
New Girl isn't quite in the highest tier of the comedy shows I've watched, but it definitely has its moments. In this delightful episode from the show's sophomore season, Jess Day (Zooey Deschanel) ends up hosting both of her separated parents at her apartment on Thanksgiving. She turns this into a series of "Parent trap" hijinks, scheming to get the two back together. It should probably be mentioned that Jess's parents are played by no less than Jamie Lee Curtis and Rob Reiner, and the presence of two such charismatic actors adds immense value to all of the episode's shenanigans.
9. Thanksgiving (Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Season 1 Episode 10)
"The whole holiday is based on over-eating. We should be wearing velvet tracksuits and diapers"
While the first season of Brooklyn Nine-Nine had its growing pains, it also had its own endearing charm. This is especially evident in episodes like Thanksgiving, where the squad's Thanksgiving (or, as Boyle (Charles Lo Truglio) calls it, 'Turkey Day') party at Amy Santiago's (Melissa Fumero) apartment turns into chaos - yet gets an ultimately heartwarming conclusion. The highlight is probably the cold open, where everyone plays 'Boyle Bingo' based on their dorky colleague's typical Thanksgiving behavior.
8. Three Turkeys (Modern Family, Season 6 Episode 8)
"God knows I couldn't love them more, but even the Kennedys didn't get together this often"
There is a certain formula that occurs in many of Modern Family's finest episodes - several intertwining schemes, misunderstandings and disagreements simmer in the background for most of the episode's duration, until it all comes together and unravels in a chaotic final act full of payoffs. One of the best examples of this trope is the season 6 episode Three Turkeys, where multiple cleverly built plot threads lead to one hell of a conclusion, with the episode's titular set of three different Thanksgiving turkeys at the epicenter of it all. Hilarity ensues.
7. Rick & Morty's Thanksploitation Spectacular (Rick and Morty, Season 5 Episode 6)
"Fun's fun, but now the Federal Government is gonna be pissed again. Way to go. And on America's birthday...or whatever the fuck Thanksgiving is"
Normal shows do normal Thanksgiving episodes, roughly speaking. Odd shows, therefore, do odd Thanksgiving episodes.
And then there's Rick and Morty, with its Thanksgiving episode where Rick (Justin Roiland) and Morty (also Justin Roiland) turn themselves into turkeys in an attempt to trick the U.S. President (Keith David) into pardoning them on Thanksgiving. No, really. That's the plot. And the results are amazing.
6. A Deep Fried Korean Thanksgiving (Gilmore Girls, Season 3 Episode 9)
"Shouldn't we give thanks first?"
"Thanks for what?"
"Well, that we're not Native Americans who got their land stolen in exchange for smallpox infested blankets"
"Amen"
I like Thanksgiving as much as the next American, but I am painfully aware of why certain citizens and especially Native Americans aren't always too keen on the holiday, as the lore behind the holiday has gone somewhat hand in hand with downplaying some of the atrocities in American history that people don't like to talk about - therefore I appreciate it when TV shows celebrating the holiday take this into consideration, as is the case with the dark-humorous and poignant quote by the wonderful Luke Danes (Scott Paterson) that I chose to represent the episode.
Beyond that well-deserved dig at America's history, most of this Gilmore Girls episode is just loads of fun. The titular Gilmore Girls Lorelai (Lauren Graham) and Rory (Alexis Bledel) face their greatest challenge yet as iconic over-eaters, as they scramble to fit in four different Thanksgiving dinners that they were invited to, while the charming Dave Rygalski (Adam Brody) steals the heart of Lane Kim (Keiko Agena) and of every viewer. Following the colorful small town of Stars Hollow celebrate Thanksgiving is an absolute delight, with perhaps the most entertaining bit being the subplot of the ever-obscure Kirk Gleason (played by the equally obscure Sean Gunn) buying a cat, who is naturally also named Kirk.
5. The Gang Squashes Their Beefs (It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, Season 9 Episode 10)
"Okay, alright, let's not get into a whole thing about missing eyes and whose fault they are"
In last December's ranking of my favorite Christmas TV episodes, I mentioned how brilliant it was that an anti-sitcom like It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia had done an 'anti-Christmas episode', twisting the clichés of typical yuletide TV specials to the point of Frank Reynolds (Danny DeVito) bursting buck-naked out of a couch, while Charlie Kelly (Charlie Day) utters the iconic line "Did you fuck my mom, Santa Claus?". If there's one series in the world that I like to recommend but "isn't for everyone", it's this one. Anyways, it's no surprise that the ever-creative dark comedy has also done a Thanksgiving episode in its 14-season (and counting) run - and that it was every bit as convention-defying and hysterically dark as the legendary A Very Sunny Christmas was.
As is often the case, the schemes and shenanigans of this It's Always Sunny episode begin with pure and good intentions - the gang wants to 'squash their beefs' that they've made over the years. To the delight of longtime viewers, this means that various recurring characters who have grievances with the gang from over the years are invited over for Thanksgiving dinner - these fan favorites include the creepy McPoyle brothers (Jimmi Simpson and Nate Mooney), television's most upsetting character arch Rickety Cricket (David Hornsby) and the hilariously eccentric and off-putting Gail the Snail, played by 24's Mary Lynn Rajskub out of all people. Things soon turn dark, and wonderfully entertaining at that, making for the perfect IASIP way to celebrate the day of giving thanks.
4. Bart vs. Thanksgiving (The Simpsons, Season 2 Episode 7)
"Hello, operator! Give me the number for 911!"
Emotional The Simpsons episodes are like deep AC/DC songs (looking at you, Ride On) - they occur so rarely, that when they do, it hits extra hard because you didn't expect it. One of the few truly touching The Simpsons episodes, alongside Bart Gets an F and And Maggie Makes Three (the quotes "You don't understand! I really tried this time!" and "Do it for her" will likely water the eyes of true fans), this semi-classic from the show's early run focuses on the sibling rivalry between Bart (Nancy Cartwright) and Lisa (Yeardley Smith).
The ever-present feud between the Simpson kids takes a turn for the serious, when Bart feels he's being blamed for everything and runs away from home after ruining their Thanksgiving dinner. Much of the episode is built on typical Springfield shenanigans, but the conclusion is distinctly real and heartfelt - we get a glimpse into the established, but rarely seen, fact that Bart and Lisa do love each other despite all their fights and hardships. After being stubborn and refusing to apologize throughout the episode, Bart's heart finally softens when he overhears his sister crying and hoping that the family could enjoy Thanksgiving with Bart present. This leads to a touching and sincere moment of apology and making up, proving that despite the show's tendency for cynicism and satire, America's favorite animated sitcom also has a lot of heart from time to time.
3. Blitzgiving (How I Met Your Mother, Season 6 Episode 10)
"Where to?"
"I guess...we're going home"
"...Yeah, I don't know where that is"
How I Met Your Mother was one of the most challenging shows to choose a favorite Thanksgiving episode from. Between the cozy Minnesota atmosphere of season 1's Belly Full of Turkey, the running-gag-hilarity of season 3's Slapsgiving and season 6's hilarious yet heartfelt Blitzgiving, the decision was tough - but I had to go with the lastly mentioned one in the end.
There's just so much to love here - Lost (2004-2010) star Jorge Garcia's guest role and the subsequent clever Lost references, the lore behind the group's 'Blitz' who always misses great things, Ted's (Josh Radnor) vision of stuffing his Thanksgiving turkey with a smaller turkey in order to make a "Tur-turkey-key", and the fact that Ted's season 6 love interest Zoey (Jennifer Morrison) actually managed to be a sympathetic character for one episode, despite the fact that she's the absolute spawn of Satan. A classic episode with pretty much infinite re-watch value!
2. The One Where Ross Got High (Friends, Season 6 Episode 9)
"And Dad, you know that mailman that you got fired? He didn't steal your playboys. Ross did!"
"Yeah, well, Hurricane Gloria didn't break the porch swing. Monica did!"
"Ross hasn't worked at the museum for a year!"
"Monica and Chandler are living together!"
"Ross married Rachel in Vegas and got divorced...again!"
"I love Jacques Cousteau!"
"I wasn't supposed to put beef in the trifle!"
"I WANNA GO!"
"That's a lot of information to get in thirty seconds"
With their unified narrative structure of things being nice, then going horribly wrong and descending into an upsetting yet entertaining chain of events where people yell at each other, after which someone does something unselfish and heartwarming to save the day, so that everything feels wholesome by the end, the Thanksgiving episodes from Friends (1994-2004) are pretty much their own genre. Containing iconic moments from mockolate and "Got the keys?", through Christina Applegate and Brad Pitt stealing the spotlight with fantastic guest appearances, all the way to Chandler (Matthew Perry) in a box and the more than one occasion where a character has had their head stuck in a turkey, these episodes are television gold, and I'll definitely do a ranking of them for next year's Thanksgiving. For now, let me tell you why (after long consideration) my favorite one out of the bunch is The One Where Ross Got High.
While funny subplots, such as Rachel's (Jennifer Aniston) hilariously failed cooking attempt and the fact that Joey (Matt Le Blanc) enjoys it nonetheless ("Custard? Good. Jam? Good. Meat? Gooood"), certainly help lift the episode to greatness, its placement ahead of all the other great ones can be boiled down to one scene - just take a look at the dialogue I chose to represent the episode. The moment where long-kept secrets begin to spill in a wonderfully chaotic and escalating fashion is such a prime example of the show's way to create comedic payoffs, write clever dialogue and just be funny and entertaining as hell. Can't go wrong with this episode.
Well, when I started working on this list, I felt certain that a Friends episode would be at first place. But my list-making process proved me wrong, as I realized that there is one Thanksgiving episode that I love even more. It surprised me, although I'm guessing that if you've ever heard me talk about sitcoms or TV or life in general, I'm guessing that the series it's from won't surprise you...
1. Cooperative Escapism in Familiar Relations (Community, Season 4 Episode 5)
"I heard your Thanksgiving wasn't much better than mine. So I thought we could take some time and be grateful for our real family. The one we chose"
There's no way around it. This is my favorite Thanksgiving episode. It may be from the least good season of my favorite sitcom (although season 4 gets way too much hate from fans - they did a surprisingly good job without main writer Dan Harmon's presence), but even at the worst of times, Community always had its moments - such as this one.
Firstly, to the part that makes this into an excellent Thanksgiving TV episode in the conventional sense. One of the two parallel storylines that are followed takes place with Shirley's (Yvette Nicole Brown) relatives, as most of the study group celebrate Thanksgiving there as Shirley's guests. Upon realizing the ridiculous family drama taking place around them, our main characters retreat into the house's basement, and start to plan an escape, as Abed (Danny Pudi) turns the whole situation into a brilliant The Shawshank Redemption (1994) homage. Everyone who has ever been at an uncomfortable family gathering will fully relate to the main characters' panic, and howl with laughter at just how far they're willing to go - Troy's (Donald Glover) dramatic delivery of the line "What if we got sick?" always gets me.
Secondly, the other storyline - the one that makes this episode into one of my top favorites. At first glance, the fact that Jeff (Joel McHale) finally reunites with his father William (James Brolin), only for heartbreaking and tear-jerking drama to ensue as Jeff's well-written psychological issues are on full display, made me question whether this episode should be #1 on this particular list - maybe it's not the best Thanksgiving episode, even if it's a great episode that happens to take place on Thanksgiving, right?
Wrong.
Upon further inspection, I found that this storyline in particular makes Cooperative Escapism in Familiar Situations into a wonderful Thanksgiving episode. Just look at the quote I chose to represent the episode - at first I thought of choosing Jeff's monologue to his father about just how much him leaving screwed him up, as that is the episode's greatest moment and never fails to move me to tears with its raw and real delivery, but I found that to be a bit too upsetting for the context of "This is my favorite Thanksgiving episode, yay!". So, instead, I chose the quote from the tail end of the episode, where the characters we love turn their sour Thanksgiving experiences into a good memory by celebrating together. For those with loving families around them, such as myself, any number of conventional TV specials will feel nice to watch on this holiday, but the existence of episodes such as this one comforts me when thinking about all those who may not have the best relationship with their family.
The fact that everyone's Thanksgiving is pretty much ruined in this episode, until they realize they should be with the ones they love the most and who they are most grateful for - which, in this instance, is their group of friends - is a great reminder that we all have something to be grateful for, even if it's not the same conventional set of things for everyone. If you're like me, you can choose a more fun Thanksgiving episode that will resonate with your feeling of spending time with family, but if you're like Jeff Winger and the idea of a traditional Thanksgiving pisses you off, this episode might strike the right chord and remind you that there's something out there for every one of us.
Thank you for reading! I hope everyone has a Thanksgiving more along the lines of the feel-good endings of most of these episodes than the chaos that dominates their middle sections. I have always liked the idea of people sharing what they are thankful for on this holiday - I, for one, am extremely thankful for my loving family, the amazing friends I have around me, the various music projects I've found my way into, and the existence of things like movies and TV shows and literature that always make me excited and passionate about life even when it's the objectively shittiest month of the year. Tune in next week for a list recommended by my Aunt Donna - the top 10 movie/TV snacks!